Skip to ContentSkip to Footer
Your Local New York Independent Insurance Agency

After Hours Phone Numbers

After regular office hours, please use these phone numbers for immediate assistance. 

Insurance CompanyClaims Phone Number
Erie Insurance800-367-3743 AFTER 5:00 OR WEEKENDS 
Call our Quinton if weekday 8:30 – 5:00 pm
Progressive800-776-4737
Travelers – Personal Insurance Claims800-252-4633
Travelers – Business Insurance Claims800-238-6225
Vermont Mutual800-435-0397
The Hartford – Business / Workers Compensation / Commercial Auto Claims800-327-3636
Merchants Insurance Group – All Other Claims800-952-5246
Merchants Insurance Group – Auto Glass Claims877-446-0431
The Andover Companies800-225-0770
AmTrust888-239-3909
Chubb800-252-4670
Finger Lakes Fire & Casualty – After-Hours Claims800-724-4032
Finger Lakes Fire & Casualty – Claims607-387-6800
Midstate Mutual800-826-8520
Wayne Cooperative Insurance Company800-724-1648
Dryden Mutual800-782-0154 OR 800-556-5802
Start Saving Today!
Customer Reviews
Rated 5 out of 5

They are an excellent choice and I’m glad we switched to them over 4 years ago.

sammy best
Sammy B
Rated 5 out of 5

The very best at customer service and they represent many different companies.

Kim Maxin
Kim M
Rated 5 out of 5

...it was a great decision!

Stephen W.
Stephen W
Rated 5 out of 5

We're happy customers now, and we anticipate being so for years to come.

Stephen Walasavage
Stephen W
Rated 5 out of 5

...we look forward to being their customers for years to come!

Stephen Walasavage
Stephen W